Caerdroia

Doctor Who, Big Finish, 8th Doctor - reviewed on Monday, February 28, 2005 by Earl Green

Doctor Who: CaerdroiaThe Doctor is asleep in the interzone between worlds, and the Kro’Ka appears to torment him - only to find that it must put up with Charley and C’rizz, who quickly become aware that the Kro’Ka seems to be powerless while the Time Lord is unconscious. Once awakened, the Doctor is subjected to a kind of mind-probing technique by the Kro’Ka, but he quickly gains the upper hand on the interzone guardian, forcing it to tell him, at least in general terms, where the TARDIS is located. The Doctor follows the trail to a place called Caerdroia, a surreal world where verdant hills populated by seemingly normal cows and rabbits lead to a circular maze. But that’s not the most surreal thing about Caerdroia - topping that list is the fact that the Doctor has emerged from the interzone in what seems like three aspects of his character: one rational, one inquisitive and easily distracted, and one dark and quick to anger. Charley and C’rizz can only tag along with the three Doctors as they look for a way out of the maze - and a way to find out who’s holding the Kro’Ka’s leash.

Order this CDwritten by Lloyd Rose
directed by Gary Russell
music by Steve Foxon

Cast: Paul McGann (The Doctor), India Fisher (Charley), Conrad Westmaas (C’rizz), Stephen Perring (The Kro’Ka), Don Warrington (Rassilon)

Doctor Who: Caerdroia - Tenth Planet alternate cover artNotes: Caerdroia is a Welsh word for a labyrinth. This audio adventure received an early release - with alternate cover art (seen here) - at a Doctor Who convention in November 2004; the limited edition alternate cover version was also sold by the internet vendor Tenth Planet.

Timeline: between The Last and The Next Life

Review: An intriguing story that’s best left on the soundstage of the mind, the ever-shifting (and I don’t use that term lightly) maze passages of Caerdroia would bankrupt a movie budget, let alone a TV budget - making it a perfect idea for an audio story. The plot threads are definitely being tightened as well, finally giving some direction to the Divergent Universe arc and leading up to what is almost certainly a grand confrontation with Rassilon. If there’s a single problem with Caerdroia as a story, it’s a bit of the dreaded “info-dump” phenomenon, where weird and wacky things happen in abundance in the first three episodes, and all is explained in the fourth. (more…)

The Last

Doctor Who, Big Finish, 8th Doctor - reviewed on Monday, February 21, 2005 by Earl Green

Doctor Who: The LastOn the planet Bortresoye, a global nuclear war has laid waste to the surface and the planet’s entire population is wiped out. The Doctor, Charley and C’rizz arrive here, driven thorugh the interzone by the Kro’Ka, who delays the Time Lord briefly to haunt him with memories of fallen companions. They seek shelter in a bombed-out building, but it collapses underneath and on top of them, leaving Charley paralyzed from the neck down and the Doctor buried under the rubble. C’rizz goes to get help, but can find only a strangely circumspect being who calls himself Requiem. The Doctor and Charley are found by a survey team and brought to a well-protected underground bunker where the planet’s only survivors are barely managing to stay alive - and earthquake damage to their bunker is slowly whittling down even that population. The ruler of one of Bortresoye’s warring nations, the Lady Excelsior, terrifies her two surviving cabinet ministers with her ability to remain blissfully deluded about the outcome of the war, and her insistence on consorting with a mysterious man named Landscar.

Order this CDwritten by Gary Hopkins
directed by Gary Russell
music by David Darlington

Cast: Paul McGann (The Doctor), India Fisher (Charley), Conrad Westmaas (C’rizz), Stephen Perring (The Kro’Ka), Carolyn Jones (Excelsior), Ian Brooker (Minister Voss), Robert Hines (Minister Tralfinial), Richard Derrington (Landscar), Tom Eastwood (Requiem), Jane Hills (Nurse), John Dorney (Make-Up Assistant)

Notes: Kro’Ka tortures the Doctor with visions of two of his fallen comrades. Katarina, a slave girl who joined the first Doctor in the 1965 TV story The Myth Makers, died trying to save the Doctor and Steven in her second story, The Daleks’ Masterplan. Adric was the young mathematical genius who stowed away on the TARDIS when the fourth Doctor, Romana and K-9 visited his home planet of Alzarius in Full Circle, and, after seeing the Doctor through his regeneration, died in an attempt to avert a Cybermen strike on Earth in Earthshock. They are two of the only three companions to have died in the original television series (the third, Sara Kingdom, joined and left the series within the 12 episodes of The Daleks’ Masterplan). Roz Forrester, a companion from the New Adventures novels, also met an untimely end in the book “So Vile A Sin”, but was not mentioned here.

Timeline: between Faith Stealer and Caerdroia

Review: An interesting and fatalistic story, The Last finally addresses a complaint of mine by allowing Conrad Westmaas to take center stage as C’rizz, minus mind control or any other story devices that would have him acting out of character. In only five stories since his introduction, C’rizz has intermittently fallen under some kind of control or possession in three, so this is really the first opportunity since Creed Of The Kromon that he’s had to be himself through the whole story, and it’s a treat. Despite his peaceful nature, we do get to see what makes his blood boil, and his approach to problem solving. I really liked what I heard - hopefully this character will continue beyond the Divergent Universe cycle of stories. (more…)

Faith Stealer

Doctor Who, Big Finish, 8th Doctor - reviewed on Monday, February 14, 2005 by Earl Green

Doctor Who: Faith StealerStill wandering through the Divergent Universe without the safety of the TARDIS, the Doctor, Charley and C’rizz suspiciously follow the Kro’ka to a place called the Multihaven. A melting pot of multiple religious beliefs, the Multihaven tolerates all of them equally, and dozens of churches have been established there. And any safe haven would be a blessing for C’rizz, plagued by memories of fulfilling his mate’s request for a mercy killing in the Kromon biosphere; the memories have taken on a new intensity of late, at times rendering him almost helpless. The Doctor and Charley leave C’rizz in the care of a peaceful sect of monks while they set out to explore the Multihaven, but while they’re gone, C’rizz’s caretakers themselves wind up on the wrong end of a hostile merger with another religion. The 23rd Church of Lucidianism is gaining new recruits at a rapid rate, even converting long-standing members of other established religions in the Multihaven. The Lucidians’ leader, Lan Carder, has more than just charisma on his side - and the Doctor suspects that the object of the Lucidians’ worship may be an alien force with a sinister agenda.

Order this CDwritten by Graham Duff
directed by Gary Russell
music by Russell Stone

Cast: Paul McGann (The Doctor), India Fisher (Charley), Conrad Westmaas (C’rizz), Stephen Perring (The Kro’Ka), Christian Rodska (Laan Carder), Tessa Shaw (The Bordinan), Jenny Coverack (Miraculite), Ifan Huw Dafydd (Bishop Parrash), Helen Kirkpatrick (Jebdal), Neil Bett (Director Garfolt), Chris Walter-Evans (The Bordinan’s Assistant), John Dorney (Bakoan), Jane Hills (L’Da)

Timeline: between The Twilight Kingdom and The Last

Review: It’s fairly clever, this one, but something about it hits me the wrong way. I don’t mind the occasional Doctor Who story with a social agenda - it’s a proud tradition dating back to the early 60s, in fact. But - and admittedly maybe I just misinterpreted the whole thing - Faith Stealer seems to be a bit of an exercise in ejecting the baby with the bathwater. Religion, faith, belief without tangible proof, all of these things are all bad, it would seem, according to the story’s writer. There are few places in the story where any of these ways of thinking get a sympathetic shake, much less a fair one. But perhaps I’m missing the point somehow. Sure, the Doctor in all of his lives has always railed against baseless superstition, con artists who are using the cover of showing people a better way of life, and so on. So the Doctor-as-debunker element of the story tracks just fine, and Paul McGann plays it admirably. (more…)

Medicinal Purposes

Doctor Who, Big Finish, 6th Doctor - reviewed on Monday, February 7, 2005 by Earl Green

Doctor Who: Medicinal PurposesThe Doctor and Evelyn arrive in Scotland, and the Doctor quickly deduces that they’ve arrived at the time of the infamous string of grave robberies attributed to Burke & Hare. But things are not as they should be - the Doctor begins to notice that certain things are out of place, and certain elements of history are not as they should be. The time travelers quickly find out why history seems to be playing out differently than recorded: they’re not the only ones there with a TARDIS.

Order this CDwritten by Robert Ross
directed by Gary Russell
music by David Darlington

Cast: Colin Baker (The Doctor), Maggie Stables (Evelyn), Leslie Phillips (Dr. Robert Knox), David Tennant (Daft Jamie), Glenna Morrison (Mary Patterson), Kevin O’Leary (William Burke), Tom Farrelly (Billy Hare), Janie Booth (Old Woman)

Notes: The villain in this story claims to have procured his TARDIS second-hand on the planet Gryben; that planet is mentioned in the Gallifrey audio miniseries as a stronghold set aside by the universe’s time-traveling superpowers to detain any time travelers who gain access to time without having developed sufficiently enough to use that ability maturely and harmlessly.

Timeline: after Arrangements For War

Review: A number of the writers who have worked on the Big Finish Doctor Who audio adventures have expressed a view that Colin Baker’s portrayal of the Doctor is perfect for the kind of pseudo-historical stories that really vanished with William Hartnell’s era, and they may well be right. This is another such story, with a little bit of a science fiction twist to it, but it makes a nearly-fatal flaw of being rather dry for much of its first half. Newcomer Robert Ross is to be commended for a script with sharp characterizations and a keen eye toward the historical events being portrayed, but when part one’s cliffhanger moment is the mere oddity that two of the historical figures who should know each other apparently don’t, you’re in trouble - it’s an interesting beat for the middle of an episode, but as a cliffhanger is just doesn’t have the necessary oomph. We’re almost to the end of part two before the presence of another time traveler becomes apparent. Maybe I’m being a bit harsh, but despite the wonderful subtleties of the historical elements of the story, there’s a certain standard required by a cliffhanger moment in Doctor Who. Slight disconnects with established history that may or may not be readily apparent to the listener don’t really seem to rise to the occasion. (more…)

14 queries. 1.835 seconds.
Powered by Wordpress
theme by evil.bert