The Scream Of The Shalka

Doctor Who, BBC, Other Doctors - reviewed on Monday, July 26, 2004 by Philip R. Frey

Richard E. Grant as the 9th DoctorThe Doctor, now in his ninth generation, finds himself in 2003 England. The small town he has been sent to (by powers unknown) has been overcome by strange, ground-dwelling creatures known as the Shalka. The Shalka keep the townspeople under their thrall with the ever-present threat of destruction. The Doctor comes to realize that the Shalka use sound as their weapon and turns that weapon against them. What he doesn’t realize is that the plan is much bigger than simply taking over one small town in England. All over the world similar towns are being invaded, their populations being slowly, subtly altered. Once complete, these humans can be used as a conduit to bring about the destruction of the Earth by way of a scream that will alter the Earth’s atmosphere, making it habitable for the Shalka, but little else. While combating this latest threat to the Earth, the Doctor tries to deal with the demons of his past and find his way in the Universe.

written by Paul Cornell
directed by Wilson Milam
music by Russell Stone

Cast: Richard E. Grant (The Doctor), Sophie Okonedo (Alison), Craig Kelly (Joe), Andrew Dunn (Max), Anna Calder-Marshall (Matilda), Conor Moloney (Dawson / Greaves), Ben Morrison (McGrath), Derek Jacobi (The Master), Diana Quick (Prime), Jim Norton (Kennet)

Review: On July 11, 2003 the BBC’s Web Site, BBCi, made a stunning announcement: Doctor Who would be returning, but not in a way anyone had expected. Well, not anyone who wasn’t paying close attention to what BBCi had been up to over the last few years. Starting with Death Comes To Time in 2000, BBCi had been producing or commissioning a series of webcasts to be shown on the BBCi site. Death Comes To Time, a completed version of an aborted Seventh Doctor radio series, was followed by Real Time, an original Sixth Doctor adventure produced by Big Finish and then by another Big Finish product, Shada, modified from Douglas Adams’ fourth Doctor story into an eighth Doctor adventure.

In all of these, BBCi had not strayed far from the formula the other major Doctor Who outlets followed: new or re-worked tales of “past” Doctors. With the new webcast, entitled The Scream of the Shalka, they would finally advance the timeline: Richard E. Grant would step into the TARDIS as the ninth Doctor. (Side note: the earliest announcements concerning Shalka refer to Richard E. Grant as “the ninth Doctor.” Later announcements would amend this to say “BBCi’s ninth Doctor,” leaving Grant’s status as a “proper” Doctor unclear.) (more…)

Death Comes To Time (CD release)

Doctor Who, BBC, 7th Doctor - reviewed on Monday, July 19, 2004 by Earl Green

Doctor Who: Death Comes To TimeThe planet Santiny is overrun by a massive invasion by a Canisian fleet. Even suicide runs don’t prevent the Canisians, as their leader, General Tannis, seems to be able to forsee every possible tactic. Almost as if in answer to the prayers of the survivors on Santiny, the TARDIS arrives, and the Doctor and his blue-skinned companion Antimony emerge to begin helping Santiny’s resistance movement. Meanwhile, Ace - planted in a strategic position by the Doctor - has been rescued by a Time Lord named Casmus, who begins training her for the next step in her own evolution. Elsewhere, a group of Time Lords called the Fraction, dedicated to interference in time on the side of good, begin falling one by one to a stealthy killer. Finally, the string of deaths draws the Doctor’s attention away from the Canisian problem, and also gets the attention of Casmus. On Gallifrey, Casmus accelerates Ace’s training, speeding her evolution into a new breed of Time Lord. Time is running out, as Tannis is also revealed to be a Time Lord who is using his conquests to disguise his identity. But will Ace learn to use her powers for good soon enough to confront Tannis, or will the Doctor - having witnessed Antimony’s death at the general’s hands - be forced to use his Time Lord powers to a degree that will not only kill Tannis but himself as well?

Order this CDwritten by Colin Meek
directed by Dan Freedman
music by Nick Romero

Cast: Sylvester McCoy (The Doctor), Sophie Aldred (Ace), Kevin Eldon (Antimony), John Sessions (General Tannis), Leonard Fenton (Casmus), Jon Culshaw (Golcrum / Senator Hawk / President), Jacqueline Pearce (Admiral Mettna), Stephen Fry (The Minister Of Chance), Britta Gartner (Senator Sala), Anthony Stewart Head (St. Valentine), Dave Hill (Nessican), Charlotte Palmer (Dr. Cain), Stephen Brody (Speedwell), Gareth Jones (Campion), Andrew McGibbon (Captain Carne), Michael Yale (Lieutenant Suneel), Peggy Batchelor (The Kingmaker), David Evans (Pilot), Robert Rietti (Premier Bedloe), Julienne Davis (Computer), Emma Ferguson (Megan), Huw Thomas (President of Santiny), Nick Romero (Major Bander / Prime Minister), Nicholas Courtney (Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart), David Soul (Bob)

Originally broadcast from July 12, 2001 to May 30, 2002

Review: A strangely epic attempt to “re-imagine” huge expanses of Doctor Who mythology and continuity, Death Comes To Time isn’t really bad, just a bit puzzling. Producer Dan Freedman has stated on numerous occasions that he felt it was necessary to re-invent the series in order to give it a shot at eturning to television, but…wow. Who knew he’d reinvent it quite so much? UNIT with space battleships? Ace becoming a Time Lord? And then, there’s the death of the Doctor himself. Not a regeneration (though to a certain extent things are left a bit vague), but a fatal blow. I hate to spoil so major a story development, but it’s necessary to reveal that point - if not its context or its place in the plot - in order to really discuss why Death Comes To Time resulted in a fan backlash to made Freedman withdraw his bid to follow the story up on TV.

In a way, one can almost compare it to the backlash that Star Trek: Generations invited by killing off Captain Kirk, though the multigeneration approach to the Star Trek franchise has bestowed upon that series’ saga an endless variety of nearly-interchangeable characters. But the Doctor is so central to Doctor Who…how did Dan Freedman plan to “follow up” on this story on television, and still call the result “Doctor Who”? If anything, Death Comes To Time is a palatable “alternate universe” story, a what-if tale which posits a race of Time Lords with awesome, godlike powers…who, for the most part, refuse to use them. Unless, of course, they’re evil. Death Comes To Time makes for a nice sidestep into speculative territory, and fits in nicely alongside the series of Doctor Who Unbound alternate continuity stories from Big Finish. (more…)

Exile

Doctor Who, Spinoffs, Doctor Who Unbound - reviewed on Monday, July 12, 2004 by Earl Green

Doctor Who Unbound: ExileTrapped by the Time Lords and tried for the crime of interfering in history, the Doctor is scheduled to be exiled to Earth - but he escapes into his TARDIS and leaves Gallifrey. Not that this really does him much good, as he winds up trapped on Earth anyway. A few incarnations later, the Doctor’s situation has become even more unsettling - he has not only changed bodies, but changed gender as well. Without her TARDIS, the Doctor becomes bored, listless, and - with the help of two friends she makes on a job she takes to eke out a meager existence - perhaps just a little bit alcoholic. Or perhaps a lot - the Doctor begins to see and hear her previous (male) incarnation, warning her of alien invasions and labyrinthine plots against modern-day Earth. When the Time Lords send two agents to track the Doctor down and bring her back to justice (though they don’t know that the Doctor is now a woman), the only thing standing between the Doctor and her doom is an increasing reliance on the bottle. When it comes right down to it, which oblivion will the Doctor choose?

Order this CDwritten by Nicholas Briggs
directed by Nicholas Briggs
music by Nicholas Briggs

Cast: Arabella Weir (The Doctor), Hannah Smith (Cherrie), Jeremy James (Cheese), Toby Longworth (Time Lord #1), David Tennant (Time Lord #2), Graham Duff (Mr. Baggit), Nicholas Briggs (The previous Doctor)

Timeline: after Logopolis - the Doctor’s sacrifice in that episode is said to be a suicide, and a non-fatal suicide attempt triggers not only a regeneration, but a gender change, in Time Lords!

Review: I try to avoid spoilers and discussions about Big Finish’s Doctor Who audios before I have the chance to hear them myself, but it was almost impossible to do so where Exile was concerned. Message boards and mailing lists glowed white-hot with speculation of which actress would make a good Doctor, then whether or not comedienne and author Arabella Weir was a good choice, and then just how bad everyone seemed to think that Exile was. I had to set aside some personal distaste for stories treating alcoholism as something less than serious, until I realized that the story actually addresses that and takes a game swipe at resolving it. The point of all this is: it was hard to listen to Exile with zero prejudice. But I was so stunned by the fan reaction that I was determined to get through the story and find something good about it. (more…)

Deadline

Doctor Who, Spinoffs, Doctor Who Unbound - reviewed on Monday, July 5, 2004 by Earl Green

Doctor Who Unbound: DeadlineMartin Bannister, in 1961, was voted one of the Times‘ ten most promising young writers for his innovative stage plays. But he tried to venture into television, and was recruited for a new BBC science fiction program called Doctor Who. Despite his extraordinary efforts to define the show’s characters, themes and parameters, Martin watched as Doctor Who made it as far as one failed pilot episode before being abandoned by the BBC. Now, 40 years later, Martin is confined to a nursing home, subjected to unsettling visits by his adult son, who’s still bitter that Martin divorced his mother when he was only six. Martin isn’t sure what is the truth and what isn’t from what his son tells him, and this isn’t the only place he’s having problems with reality - he imagines a burgeoning romance with a nurse, he imagines that he’s being tapped to write the celebratory 40th anniversary comeback of Doctor Who (but why celebrate a show that was never made?), and he imagines that he is the Doctor, that most mysterious traveler in time and space. Will Martin Bannister trade his unpromising reality for an unrealized fantasy?

Order this CDwritten by Rob Shearman
directed by Nicholas Briggs
music by Nicholas Briggs

Cast: Sir Derek Jacobi (Martin), Genevieve Swallow (Susan), Peter Forbes (Philip), Jacqueline King (Barbara), Ian Brooker (Sydney), Adam Manning (Tom)

Timeline: 40 years after Doctor Who was rejected by the BBC

Review: An extraordinarily affecting piece of drama, Deadline stretches the concept of metafiction to breaking point, and then keeps on pushing. Hard. At several points, the listener really has to make his own judgement - based on what’s happened so far - about which of these scenarios is reality for Martin. And it’s not made easy - at many turns, Martin is a tragic and yet not entirely sympathetic character. He is, by turns, a crotchety, lovable old wanderer in space-time, and an utter bastard to everyone around him. But who’s really around him? Or is it Who that’s really around him? (more…)

13 queries. 3.368 seconds.
Powered by Wordpress
theme by evil.bert